The Drowned Heir, by Jennifer R. Donohue
14 Jan 2026The Book

Synopsis:
When her uncle dies at sea, a third child with no place in society undergoes a ceremony to house his spirit and take his role, diminishing the family’s loss. But her uncle’s spirit hasn’t settled the way it’s supposed to, and will not content itself with shore-bound business. Her uncle’s spirit insists, angrily, that it was not just a storm that killed him and wrecked his ship, not a rogue wave; it was an unthinkably large monster.
Then his lover comes knocking with news of an adult son who has set sail along the same shipping lane, and dead uncle and living niece must work together to save a son neither of them knew existed.
My Review
The Drowned Heir is a maritime fantasy novella written by Jennifer R. Donohue which I've read as part of the SFINCS' semifinals. An interesting proposal full of imagery and which stands out with its use of a prose that borders the lyrical, and the way it tackles a theme such as shared identity.
A novella that opens with our main character being drowned as part of the traditions of her town; a ritual that allows her deceased uncle's spirit to take over the body, becoming the closest thing to an heir the captain left behind. She's not sure the ritual went well, as she's unsure if her own spirit should still be in the body, fighting with the captain's; she clings to the hope that this means there might be an actual heir, one her uncle wasn't aware.
When the captain's lover shows up asking for his help, the main character, dominated by the captain's spirit, is determined to sail once more and face the monster that caused his death.
Using a first person as the narrative voice was a clever decision by Donohue, as it allows the reader to understand the fight and the struggle of the main character, how she's trying to cling to her identity while the captain is trying to gain control over his; a situation that is accelerated after the captain receives the news from her lover.
The prose is full of atmospherical details, and also helps to capture this struggle between two people that actually appreciate and love each other, as they were family; the pacing works well, making this a great bite-sized piece to read.
The Drowned Heir is a promising novella, a clever proposal that is enhanced by Donohue's prose use; couldn't have chosen a better way to start my semifinals reads.
Disclaimer: This novella has been read as part of the SFINCS. This review/rating only represents my personal opinion and it might differ with what the team decides.
The Author/s

Jennifer R. Donohue
Jennifer R. Donohue grew up at the Jersey Shore and now lives in central New York with her husband and their Doberman. A member of the SFWA, she works at her local public library where she also facilitates a writing workshop. Her work has appeared in Apex Magazine, Escape Pod, Fusion Fragment, and elsewhere. Her debut novel, Exit Ghost is available now.
