They Fear Not Men in the Woods, by Gretchen McNeil

1 Oct 2025

The Book

They Fear Not Men in the Woods
Pages: 383
Age Group: Adult
Published on 9 Sept 2025
Publisher: DAW Books
Genres:
Horror

Synopsis:

For fans of Midsommar, Catriona Ward, and Sarah Gailey, this addictively readable modern horror novel unfolds like a movie with a climax you’ll never see coming

When Jen Monroe hears her father’s remains have been found, she returns home to disprove his death, only to find the forests of rural Washington are hiding horrors beyond imagining

Seven years ago, Jen Monroe left behind her hometown of Barrow, Washington after her father, a forest ranger passionate about protecting old trees from the aggressive logging business that runs their small town, vanished seemingly into thin air. She vowed never to return…until she gets a text from her estranged mother. Her father’s remains have been found.

It seems impossible to Jen who has always believed her father is still alive, and she returns home, determined to find out what really happened. When her ex-boyfriend proposes a camping trip into the woods in her father’s memory, it feels like the opportunity Jen had been hoping for: to find her father. To find the truth.

But what she finds lurking in the ancient, impenetrable forest may be deeper, darker and deadlier than she could have ever imagined. And it has no intention of letting her leave.

Deeply unsettling and thoroughly creepy, this is feminist horror for those who have always known there’s something waiting in the woods.

My Review

They Fear Not Men in the Woods is a horror novel written by Gretchen McNeil, published by DAW Books. A slow-burn horror story that makes the best of the inherent fear of the wild places, vast forests, delivering an eerie and atmospheric plot bordering on a study of small towns and how difficult is to leave all the baggage attached to ourselves behind.

Six years after her father's disappearing in the Washington wilderness, Jen Monroe returns to her hometown to bury what seems to be his remains. Not really convinced that they are his, she soon finds herself on a new trek into the woods with a particular group: her ex-boyfriend (and son of the lumber company owner), her best friend and her boyfriend, two other male hikers and a mysterious Finnish girl called Sammy. As they venture deeper into the forest, strange things begin to happen; a build-up that keeps getting deeper into the mystery, into that danger that our group is experiencing.

Characterization can be one of the weak points of this novel: not only we have an unlikeable main character as Jen Monroe, but I would also argue that most of the rest of the group is a bit underdeveloped. The small-town trope is well used, almost becoming a synonym with the baggage that is attached to Jen's life, including the grief she still feels for her father: overcoming it is part of the reason for this trek.

Said that, the setting is one highlight of the novel: the vast forests of the PNW are the perfect place for such a kind of horror, with a heavy atmospherical component that also plays into some of the most primal fears of the mind. 
In terms of pacing, we have two clearly different parts: a first one, slower, that introduces us to the characters that will become part of the trek; and a second one, that starts around the 50% mark, that is where the horror elements are introduced. While it worked for me, I can understand it might not be for everybody.

They Fear Not Men in the Woods is an interesting horror novel, a good choice if you like atmosphere-heavy reads with a touch of character drama; a debut into the genre that shows promising ideas.

The Author/s

Gretchen McNeil

Gretchen McNeil

Gretchen McNeil is the author of the YA horror/suspense novels POSSESS, 3:59, RELIC, GET EVEN, GET DIRTY, and TEN (a YALSA Top Ten Quick Pick for Reluctant Young Adult Readers, a Romantic Times Top Pick, and a Booklist Top Ten Horror Fiction for Youth) all with Balzer + Bray for HarperCollins. Gretchen’s first YA contemporary I’M NOT YOUR MANIC PIXIE DREAM GIRL, also with Balzer + Bray, hit shelves in 2016, and then she returned to her horror-comedy roots with #MURDERTRENDING (Barnes & Noble Best Books of 2018, ILA 2019 Young Adults’ Choices Reading list, YALSA’s 2019 Quick Picks for Reluctant Young Readers, and was voted the #1 choice on YALSA’s 2019 Teens’ Top Ten list) and the sequel #MURDERFUDNING (2020 YALSA Teens’ Top Ten) for Disney/Freeform. The companion novel #NOESCAPE was a YALSA 2021 Quick Pick for Reluctant Readers. Her most recent novel is DIG TWO GRAVES, followed by THREE DROPS OF BLOOD in 2023 and FOUR-LETTER WORD in 2024, all for Disney-Hyperion.

Gretchen’s novels have been published internationally in over a dozen languages. Ten: Murder Island, the film adaptation of TEN starring China Anne McClain (Descendants 2, Black Lightning) premiered on Lifetime in 2017, and GET EVEN and GET DIRTY have been adapted as the series Get Even and Rebel Cheer Squad: a Get Even series for BBC and Netflix